Government dependency refers to the state of a household being dependent on government welfare benefits. The topic is a central point of contention in American politics, touching on fundamental questions about individual responsibility and the role of the government. This has caused an ideological divide as Government dependency appears to be a considerable concern for Republican voters. Polling indicates that 68% of Republicans view entitlements negatively, believing that they create dependency, while 71% of Democratic voters believe the opposite. Additionally, the Republican platform expresses concern regarding government dependency several times.
Those concerned with government dependency point to the large spending that welfare programs cause the federal government. There is also a fear that welfare programs disincentivize work by reducing the financial need to seek employment. On the other hand, supporters of these programs argue that they are a crucial lifeline, as many recipients are children, the elderly, or individuals who genuinely cannot work due to disabilities. They also see these programs as a tool to break the cycle of poverty by improving the lives of children in low-income families.
The Democratic Stance on Government Dependency.
The Democratic Party supports government welfare programs and views them as a necessary component of a fair society, rather than a source of problematic dependency. A significant example of this stance is the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021, signed by former President Joe Biden. This act expanded social programs by tripling the maximum Earned Income Tax Credit for millions of low-income workers, increasing SNAP (food stamp) benefits, and expanding the Child Tax Credit.
The 2024 Democratic Party Platform frames welfare policy as providing Americans with a fair shot, and not an issue of dependency. The platform argues that most people seek help, not a handout; therefore, democrats advocate for pouring more resources into welfare and support systems.
Democrats believe that Americans on welfare programs are already working or are temporarily between jobs. According to the left-leaning Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, non-working adult recipients are typically unable to work due to health problems, are caring for family members, or are enrolled in school.
The party’s focus aligns with the views of the party’s voters. Data shows that 76% of Democratic voters say that government aid to the poor has an overall positive effect. Additionally, 72% of Democrats say that the modern government policies should do more to help the needy.
The Republican Stance on Government Dependency
The Republican Party’s political stance is that government dependency is a significant and growing problem in the United States. According to a report from the House Ways and Means Committee, chaired by Representative Jason Smith, government welfare programs are harmful. Welfare disincentivizes work and fosters government dependency. The committee’s position is that struggling families need good-paying jobs instead of government money.
In line with this view, Republicans have consistently advocated for expanding work requirements for welfare eligibility. A recent example is the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed into law by President Trump. This legislation significantly cut federal spending from the nutrition funding program SNAP and the low-income health insurance program Medicaid, aiming to reduce federal nutrition funding by $186 billion between 2025 and 2034. The act also expanded the SNAP eligibility work requirement to include adults ages 18-64, an increase from the previous age range of 18-54. Furthermore, it introduced work requirements to the Medicaid recipient, mandating that adults 19 to 64 are required to work at least 80 hours per month, with similar exceptions to those of SNAP work requirements.
This approach aligns with the view of many Republican voters. Pew Research Center data shows that Republican voters also tend to be critical of government aid and welfare to the poor, as 65% say that government aid does more harm than good. Most advocate for external organizations like religious and private institutions to hold this responsibility.
Brief History of Government Dependency in the US
Large-scale U.S. government policy for welfare originated during the national economic crisis of the Great Depression. The Social Security Act of 1935 was enacted to create a permanent economic safety net for the American public. It established three main types of programs: unemployment insurance, old age and survivors insurance (Social Security), and assistance programs for aged, blind, and dependent children.
By the 1970s, a growing political concern about government dependency emerged. In 1976, President Ronald Reagan famously introduced the narrative of the “welfare queen,” which depicted individuals who committed welfare fraud to get money from the government without working. This rising concern culminated in 1996 when President Bill Clinton signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act. To have individuals stop depending on the government, the act fundamentally reformed welfare by requiring recipients to begin working after two years of receiving benefits and placing a lifetime limit of five years on benefits paid by federal funds. This effectively ended welfare as a lifelong entitlement program
Despite this reform, the proportion of the U.S. population receiving government assistance has grown. This growth is evident across several key programs. The percentage of the population on Medicaid grew from 9.3 percent in 1975 to 24.3 percent in 2022. Over the same period, recipients of SNAP increased from 7.9 percent in 1975 to 12.4 percent of the population. The Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) grew from 2.9 percent in 1975 to 9.3 percent in 2021, and Supplemental Security Income (SSI) grew from 2 percent in 1975 to 2.3 percent the same year.
Public Opinion on Government Dependency
A national survey done by the Cato Institute reveals a nuanced public opinion on welfare. Although Americans don’t believe that existing public policies will eliminate poverty, most don’t see welfare programs as problematic. Only 45% of people believe that welfare makes poor people dependent on the government. However, 54% of people believe welfare programs offer people an opportunity to get back on their feet.
Among people currently receiving government benefits, a large majority of 68% believe that welfare programs help people instead of fostering dependency. 50% of nonrecipients believe the same. Views also differ across racial demographics, as 67% of African Americans and 64% of Latino Americans don’t believe that welfare creates dependency, while only 49% of white Americans hold the same view.
While there is a majority support for government welfare programs, there is also a broad consensus that there are better ways to help the poor and prevent government dependency. The same national survey found that 70% of people believe the government should focus on eliminating the root causes of poverty rather than just providing welfare benefits. Moreover, 79% of people say that economic growth will do more to help the poor than increased welfare spending, and 72% of Americans believe that even with unlimited funds, the government would be unable to eliminate poverty through welfare alone.
What the Future Holds
The debate over government dependency tends to be about whether providing a robust safety net or promoting self-sufficiency is more important and helpful to the poor. Therefore, the future of this issue will likely have to balance these two narratives.
Welfare public policy will probably be shaped by prevailing economic conditions and the political party in power. During recessions, public support of government aid tends to increase, and during periods of economic growth, the focus often shifts back to concern about dependency, spending, and reform.
To compare political parties’ views on other key policy topics, visit Biasly’s full list of Political Party Policy Stances.
To unlock more data-driven insights into media bias, explore political leanings with research-backed tools, and customize your news feed around what matters most to you, sign up for a Biasly Premium News Membership.