Justices appear skeptical of affirmative action during oral arguments (plus the Elizabeth Warren question)

  • Bias Rating

    2% Center

  • Reliability

    N/AN/A

  • Policy Leaning

    78% Extremely Conservative

  • Politician Portrayal

    58% Negative

Bias Score Analysis

The A.I. bias rating includes policy and politician portrayal leanings based on the author’s tone found in the article using machine learning. Bias scores are on a scale of -100% to 100% with higher negative scores being more liberal and higher positive scores being more conservative, and 0% being neutral.

Sentiments

Overall Sentiment

N/A

  •   Liberal
  •   Conservative
SentenceSentimentBias
"How, the court's conservative justices asked, will supporters of the policies determine whether the goals of affirmative action had ever been reached?"
Positive
8% Conservative
"Justice Samuel Alito likened affirmative action to a race in which a minority applicant gets to start five yards closer to the finish line."
Positive
6% Conservative
"Depending on its scope, a ruling against U.N.C. could doom affirmative action at public colleges and universities around the nation and perhaps at private ones, too."
Negative
-6% Liberal
"There does seem to be agreement that affirmative action matters much less at the majority of colleges which aren't as highly competitive as Harvard."
Negative
-6% Liberal
"Most colleges do not use affirmative action when they decide which students to accept."
Negative
-6% Liberal
"Alito asked North Carolina Solicitor General Ryan Park -- who is defending affirmative action policies at the University of North Carolina -- what is preventing students from claiming heritage they don't have."
Negative
-10% Liberal
"Simultaneously, the liberal Justices also seem to be arguing that affirmative action rarely makes a difference or that the difference is so slight that it's not clear anyone has sufficient grounds to claim injury."
Negative
-12% Liberal
"but from what I have heard it seems the liberal Justices are arguing that ending affirmative action would harm Black and Latino representation."
Negative
-18% Liberal
"But he added that a ban on affirmative action could change how students of color feel about pursuing higher education."
Negative
-20% Liberal
"Chief Justice Roberts is apparently also skeptical of affirmative action and asked when it would ever end."
Negative
-28% Liberal
"Justice Elena Kagan said she was worried about a precipitous decline in minority admissions were the court to rule against affirmative action in higher education."
Negative
-50% Liberal

Bias Meter

Extremely
Liberal

Very
Liberal

Moderately
Liberal

Somewhat Liberal

Center

Somewhat Conservative

Moderately
Conservative

Very
Conservative

Extremely
Conservative

-100%
Liberal

100%
Conservative

Bias Meter

Contributing sentiments towards policy:

54% : How, the court's conservative justices asked, will supporters of the policies determine whether the goals of affirmative action had ever been reached?
53% :Justice Samuel Alito likened affirmative action to a race in which a minority applicant gets to "start five yards closer to the finish line."
47% : Depending on its scope, a ruling against U.N.C. could doom affirmative action at public colleges and universities around the nation and perhaps at private ones, too.
47% : There does seem to be agreement that affirmative action matters much less at the majority of colleges which aren't as highly competitive as Harvard.
47% : Most colleges do not use affirmative action when they decide which students to accept.
45% : Alito asked North Carolina Solicitor General Ryan Park -- who is defending affirmative action policies at the University of North Carolina -- what is preventing students from claiming heritage they don't have.
44% : Simultaneously, the liberal Justices also seem to be arguing that affirmative action rarely makes a difference or that the difference is so slight that it's not clear anyone has sufficient grounds to claim injury.
41% : but from what I have heard it seems the liberal Justices are arguing that ending affirmative action would harm Black and Latino representation.
40% : But he added that a ban on affirmative action could change how students of color feel about pursuing higher education.
36% : Chief Justice Roberts is apparently also skeptical of affirmative action and asked when it would ever end.
25% : Justice Elena Kagan said she was worried about "a precipitous decline in minority admissions" were the court to rule against affirmative action in higher education.

*Our bias meter rating uses data science including sentiment analysis, machine learning and our proprietary algorithm for determining biases in news articles. Bias scores are on a scale of -100% to 100% with higher negative scores being more liberal and higher positive scores being more conservative, and 0% being neutral. The rating is an independent analysis and is not affiliated nor sponsored by the news source or any other organization.

Copy link